Metropolitan City of Bologna
A Job I Like or a Job I Can Get: Designing Job Recommender Systems Using Field Experiments
Bied, Guillaume, Caillou, Philippe, Crépon, Bruno, Gaillac, Christophe, Pérennes, Elia, Sebag, Michèle
Recommendation systems (RSs) are increasingly used to guide job seekers on online platforms, yet the algorithms currently deployed are typically optimized for predictive objectives such as clicks, applications, or hires, rather than job seekers' welfare. We develop a job-search model with an application stage in which the value of a vacancy depends on two dimensions: the utility it delivers to the worker and the probability that an application succeeds. The model implies that welfare-optimal RSs rank vacancies by an expected-surplus index combining both, and shows why rankings based solely on utility, hiring probabilities, or observed application behavior are generically suboptimal, an instance of the inversion problem between behavior and welfare. We test these predictions and quantify their practical importance through two randomized field experiments conducted with the French public employment service. The first experiment, comparing existing algorithms and their combinations, provides behavioral evidence that both dimensions shape application decisions. Guided by the model and these results, the second experiment extends the comparison to an RS designed to approximate the welfare-optimal ranking. The experiments generate exogenous variation in the vacancies shown to job seekers, allowing us to estimate the model, validate its behavioral predictions, and construct a welfare metric. Algorithms informed by the model-implied optimal ranking substantially outperform existing approaches and perform close to the welfare-optimal benchmark. Our results show that embedding predictive tools within a simple job-search framework and combining it with experimental evidence yields recommendation rules with substantial welfare gains in practice.
- Europe > France (0.04)
- North America > United States > Illinois > Cook County > Chicago (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- (2 more...)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (1.00)
- Research Report > Strength High (0.87)
- Banking & Finance > Economy (0.46)
- Education > Educational Setting (0.46)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Personal Assistant Systems (0.88)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Uncertainty > Bayesian Inference (0.45)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Learning Graphical Models > Directed Networks > Bayesian Learning (0.45)
- Europe > Germany > Baden-Württemberg > Tübingen Region > Tübingen (0.14)
- Europe > Germany > Bavaria > Upper Bavaria > Munich (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- (6 more...)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Instructional Material (0.67)
- Energy (0.93)
- Education > Educational Setting (0.46)
- Asia > Middle East > Jordan (0.04)
- North America > United States > Massachusetts > Middlesex County > Cambridge (0.04)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (0.93)
- Research Report > New Finding (0.67)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Vision (0.93)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (0.67)
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.14)
- Asia > Middle East > Israel > Haifa District > Haifa (0.04)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- Europe > Switzerland (0.04)
- North America > United States > North Carolina (0.04)
- North America > United States > New Jersey > Hudson County > Hoboken (0.04)
- (5 more...)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (1.00)
- Health & Medicine > Therapeutic Area > Neurology (1.00)
- Health & Medicine > Health Care Technology (0.92)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- Asia > Middle East > Jordan (0.04)
- North America > United States > California > Alameda County > Berkeley (0.04)
- (4 more...)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Statistical Learning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks (1.00)
- Information Technology > Information Management (0.68)
- North America > United States > Illinois > Champaign County > Urbana (0.04)
- North America > Canada (0.04)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- (16 more...)
- Health & Medicine > Therapeutic Area > Neurology > Parkinson's Disease (1.00)
- Health & Medicine > Therapeutic Area > Musculoskeletal (1.00)
- Europe > Sweden > Vaestra Goetaland > Gothenburg (0.04)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- Europe > Switzerland > Zürich > Zürich (0.14)
- Europe > Italy > Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna > Bologna (0.04)
- North America > United States > Florida > Broward County > Fort Lauderdale (0.04)
- (2 more...)
- Asia > Japan > Honshū > Kantō > Tokyo Metropolis Prefecture > Tokyo (0.04)
- North America > United States > Texas > Travis County > Austin (0.04)
- North America > Canada > Quebec > Montreal (0.04)
- (2 more...)
- Information Technology > Communications (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Statistical Learning (0.94)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks (0.71)